Wednesday, May 20, 2009

Why Denver Parking Tickets are a SCAM

As of this writing, I am 27 years old. I have been driving since I was 16, mostly in Texas. From the time I started driving, until the time I moved to Denver a few months ago, I had received a grand total of ONE ticket in my life (late for an exam in college and didn't get back to the meter in time).

When I first moved here, I was astounded at how few people used the parking meters...I have now learned why. Since moving to Denver, I have received no less than TEN parking tickets (more than two per month). I am a reasonable person, and I understand that parking is a limited resource, however I must say this system is UNJUST and we should FIGHT.

I am compiling research on this subject to see just what is going on in Denver to abuse their authority to such a degree.
  1. Denver parking meters have very short times (usually 2 hours max). In most cities, a parking meter is 3-4 hours. The 2 hour limit is specifically designed to generate additional fees.
  2. The cost to park is $0.25 for 1/4 hour. The fee for returning 1 minute late is $30! That means the fee is 15X to 120X the cost of the parking!
  3. Denver PVB gives the owner a 20 day window to respond to the citation. With most services (particularly those that require response by mail or physical presence) give a 30-60 day window to respond. This exceptionally short response time is designed to add additional penalites to the fine.
  4. If you do not respond to the denver parking ticket within 20 days, your fee is DOUBLED. This means your fee could potentially be 240X the cost of parking. This also means that the city is charging an effective interest rate of over 1,200% despite the legal maximum of 30%. Despite being an egregious penalty, I view this to be criminal!
  5. In 2007, vehicle control agents issued 585,211 citations, raising $16.4 million. New figures show that in 2008, agents wrote 618,556 tickets for nearly $20 million in revenue. Agents are given strict quotas of at least 90 tickets per day, regardless of triviality of the infraction.
  6. The city and county of Denver, at this time, has a population of 598,707. As the City of Denver has handed out over 600k parking tickets, they have given a ticket for every man, woman, and child within the city...and then some. If my math is correct... the city believes that 103% of Denver residents are criminals
  7. In addition to writing more Denver Parking Tickets, the PVB raised the fees in 2007. Confirming their clear effort to raise revenue, the PVB does not allow its victims to contest the fees based on economic hardship or on the unfairness of the fees.
  8. Denver PVB is biased in their grounds for increasing citations, rejecting our contestations, and in their rationale for increased fees and penalties. The city of denver serves its own interest and agenda by collecting parking ticket fees, while it has no incentive (and clearly no desire) to resolve complaints
  9. The city has hired the firm ACS Inc. to provide fancy new parking ticket machines, streamline the fee collection process, and to help provide programs to increase the number of citations delivered. In this sense, the city is acting in partnership with (and indeed in a similar fashion) to a corporation in seek of profit at the expense of its consumers.
  10. The city also refers to those who have received tickets as "customers" further cofirming Denver PVB's identity as a corporation rather than a public service. This is despite the fact that those served with a Denver Parking Ticket are unwilling "customers" and likely consider themselves victims of an increasingly abusive entity.
  11. The city is now collecting $3 in unfair fees from citations for every $1 made honestly through parking meters. The revenue from parking now accounts for over 3% of the city's general fund budget, clearly indicating that the city is now relying on these revenues. To the average person making $35k a year, this would be similar to a $1,000 bonus for cheating.
In the News
  1. City admits to over $1million in fraudulent fees: http://denver.cbslocal.com/2011/02/21/ticket-troubles-cbs4-investigation-reveals-1m-in-questionable-parking-tickets/
  2. Meter maids seek revenge and issue false citations: http://www.9news.com/news/story.aspx?storyid=162955&catid=222 and http://blogs.westword.com/latestword/2011/06/parking_ticket_contest.php
  3. Ticket payments are handled through a corporate website(denverpvb.com). This makes it difficult to distinguish legitimate tickets from false ones: http://www.9news.com/rss/story.aspx?storyid=85307
  4. The city deliberately waits to take action in order to increase fees. They use questionable tactics, such as debt collection firms to coerce payment: http://blogs.westword.com/latestword/2008/11/happy_birthday_parking_ticket.php
  5. Denver using tickets to supplement sales tax: http://blogs.westword.com/latestword/2009/02/kenny_bes_worst_case_scenario_6.php


3 comments:

  1. The parking in Denver is awful. I refuse to go to any restaurants in LoDo or anywhere else about the city.

    I have complained to the city, which you know as well as I do is useless. I've been having some fun on John Hickenlooper's Facebook page.

    I also linked to your blog post here in my blog: http://lifewithoutrulers.blogspot.com/2013/09/robin-hooding.html

    This article deals with "Robin Hooding" which deprives the city of revenue from parking citations. Check it out and let me know what you think.

    I think it's time to make this happen in Denver and elsewhere.

    Also let the merchants know that you refuse to patronize their restaurants, shops, and bars because of the city's parking enforcement.

    They won't listen to us victims, but they will listen to the businesses and merchants if they get mad enough.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I totally agree it is a scam. What I have observed, especially in Downtown Denver is that these ticket guys seems to sit somewhere, hide and watch people park, then they comes out and started issuing tickets. Few days ago, I parked my and quickly ran inside the department of revenue. Less than a minute, I was out and saw a ticket hanging on my dash. All the vehicles lined up got tickets but the very vehicle in my front did not get a ticket. To make matter worse, there was no sign of parking restriction on that spot, so many people were parking to go take care of their businesses. The activities of this guys in the name of doing their jobs is ridiculous.

    ReplyDelete
  3. On 07/21/16, I was parked on 2350 Kearney Street where my brother is in a rehabilitation facility from full spinal fusion surgery. I was in my car parked with a massive nose bleed. I saw the lady come up to my car and she quickly went back to her vehicle and placed a ticket on my car for no valid registration sticker visible on windshield. My windshield had been replaced on July 19, 2016 at Safelite on Evans. My registration sticker was mailed to me as the one on the windshield could not be saved. It expired July 2016, and it had arrived in the mail. I had it in the envelope in the car. I tried to get the meter lady's attention to help me as the nose bleed turned out to be more serious than I thought after diagnostics. I have been diagnosed with a brain aneurysm. I needed her help so instead of helping me she ignored my request and stuck a $75.00 ticket in my driver’s side passenger window and left quickly. I was unable to show her my receipt for windshield replacement or the new registration sticker I had in my car. Denver is dog friendly and homeless friendly, but when it comes to their meter people and violations while parked, Denver is not friendly. More over the lack of human kind was overwhelming. Officer Buscietta, Beat: SA Badge #: 365, I ask you to be more aware of the circumstances instead of the ticket quota for the day. The Highline Rehabilitation got me the help needed, I was in a critical medical situation. I believe in kindness, I only ask you to practice.

    ReplyDelete